HomeMy WebLinkAboutCat Tucker 11.2.pdfCAUTION: This email originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening
attachments, clicking links, or responding to this email.
From:Cat Tucker
To:All Council Members
Cc:Matt Morley
Subject:EXTERNAL - Urgent Ordinance ICE Moratorium
Date:Saturday, October 3, 2026 2:02:42 PM
Mayor and City Council Members,
First let me say that I think it is inappropriate to try and model San Jose's documents. Gilroy
has only 60,000 population and does not have the same issues as San Jose.
However, I have read the Staff analysis for the Urgent Moratorium several times and there is
so much to say about each of the recommended actions. My first thought was there is so much
to review and understand the consequences of each action that I doubt you have enough time
Monday night and therefore I am concerned that you will rush through it.
Let me just say I don't agree with Staff's assumptions in most of their analysis but especially in
regards to the statement on page 643 last paragraph. What is the tangible evidence that it is
imminent that ICE will come into the City Limits? I disagree because if that were the case,
they would have done it already before spending millions of dollars on 56 acres of land on
Holsclaw Rd. If you have direct evidence then you need to spell it out publicly. Let the public
know if a commercial real estate person gave you direct information. I disagree that there is
an imminent threat to our city that warrants an Urgent Moratorium. I view this language as
fear mongering and it feels like intimidation tactics to force the council to take immediate
action.
Also, you know darn well that any policy you make on banning ICE staging on public or
private property is not enforceable. If it was then San Francisco would have done it long ago.
Additionally, I feel you are misleading innocent people by making promises to protect them
when you know you can’t. You cannot stop ICE from patrolling our streets and you cannot
stop them from picking people up while they are out shopping or going to work.
The cruelest thing is to give people Hope that our City can protect them when in fact you
know that none of these recommendations will unfortunately protect them or our City from the
current Federal Government.
Finally, Mr. Mayor, I am very disappointed in you for putting this on the agenda during the
Election Campaign season. I cannot believe that you are Naïve to think that this discussion
item will not help your friend Candidate Christina Tovar in her campaign against Council
Member Cline. If you were truly concerned you could have brought this information forward
before now. The ICE initiative has been known by our state officials and I am sure the
November 30th deadline is not new information. Why wait until now?
In my opinion, Mr. Mayor, you are Savvy enough of a politician to see how this benefits
Candidate Armendariz with all her publicity of anti-ICE in addition to your friend Candidate
Christina Tovar as it puts Council Member Cline in a difficult position if he wants to vote
against this moratorium.
Shame on you for using your office to indirectly help your friends during the Election.
I urge all of you to think this through and take all the time you need to understand each of the
alternatives that are recommended in the report and consider the unintended consequences
that may result from these actions. (Such as restricting private property owners from using
their land/buildings) I know many people who are OK with the ICE facility on Holsclaw so pls
remember that you represent All of the people of Gilroy.
Regards,
Cat Tucker