HomeMy WebLinkAboutAnthony Abraham 11.2.pdfCAUTION: This email originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening
attachments, clicking links, or responding to this email.
From:Anthony Suárez-Abraham
To:Public Comments; Mayor Greg Bozzo; Council Member Zachary Hilton; Council Member Dion Bracco; Council
Member Tom Cline; Council Member Terence Fugazzi; Council Member Carol Marques; Council Member Kelly
Ramirez
Cc:Kim Mancera; Matt Morley
Subject:EXTERNAL - 10/5 City Council Agenda Item 11.2: Temporary Moratorium and No Staging
Date:Monday, October 5, 2026 12:28:46 PM
Dear Mayor Bozzo, Mayor Pro Tempore Hilton, and Council Members Bracco, Cline, Fugazzi, Marques,
and Ramirez,
Thank you for your leadership in unanimously adopting the June resolution opposing the development of a
federal detention facility near Gilroy. I am writing today to ask that you build upon that commitment by
supporting both the proposed temporary moratorium on detention facilities and the policy prohibiting the
use of City-owned or City-controlled property as staging areas, processing locations, or operational bases
for civil immigration enforcement activities.
I want to be transparent that I am not a resident of Gilroy. I live in neighboring Watsonville, another
agricultural community whose life is deeply intertwined with migrant and farmworker families. I serve as
Associate Pastor at Advent Lutheran Church in Morgan Hill, here in South Santa Clara County, and I also
teach theology and religious studies at Saint Mary’s College of California. Across each of those vocations,
questions of human dignity, equity, justice, and our responsibilities toward one another are not abstract
concerns. They are woven into the people and communities among whom I live, teach, and serve.
As a Christian pastor and theologian, I cannot separate questions of public life from the biblical summons to
attend especially to those whose lives are vulnerable. Israel is commanded, “You shall also love the
stranger, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt” (Deuteronomy 10:19). Jesus makes that responsibility
startlingly personal when he says, “I was a stranger and you welcomed me” (Matthew 25:35). And the
prophet Micah distills the life of faith into an enduring summons: “to do justice, and to love kindness, and to
walk humbly with your God” (Micah 6:8).
I do not offer these texts because I expect municipal government to legislate Christian theology. I offer
them because they disclose the moral tradition from which I speak. They require me to ask how our public
decisions affect those who possess the least security and power, how we safeguard the dignity of our
neighbors, and what kind of communities we choose to become when people among us are afraid.
For those reasons, I support a temporary moratorium on the filing, acceptance, processing, and approval of
applications or entitlements for new or expanded detention and custodial facilities while the City considers
their implications for the health, safety, welfare, and social fabric of the community.
I also support the proposed No Staging policy. City property ought to remain space in which residents can
seek services, work, gather, and participate in civic life without wondering whether those same public
spaces may become staging grounds for civil immigration enforcement operations. Whatever one’s views
concerning federal immigration policy, trust between residents and local government is indispensable to a
healthy community. When people become afraid to approach public institutions or participate in community
life, that trust—and the common good it makes possible—is diminished.
There is an economic dimension to this question as well. A March 2026 analysis by the Bay Area Council
Economic Institute estimates that removing undocumented workers from the Bay Area economy could
result in losses of as much as $67 billion in regional GDP, together with substantial losses in tax revenue
and household purchasing power. Its statewide research also estimates that the removal of undocumented
workers could reduce the GDP generated by California’s agricultural industry by approximately 14 percent.
Those figures matter particularly in agricultural communities such as ours, where immigrant labor, local
businesses, growers, workers, and families are deeply interconnected (Bay Area Council Economic
Institute).
But economic consequences, significant as they are, cannot be the whole measure of the matter.
Immigrant and farmworker families are woven deeply into the life of South Santa Clara County and the
neighboring agricultural communities in which I live and serve. They are not abstractions in a policy debate.
They are our neighbors and parishioners, our students and coworkers, parents and children, friends and
members of the human family.
Public policy inevitably involves difficult questions of jurisdiction, authority, law, and competing
responsibilities. I recognize those complexities. Yet I also believe that within those complexities there
remains room for communities to say clearly what they value: human dignity, public trust, the safety of
families, care for the vulnerable, and a civic life in which people are not governed principally by fear.
I therefore respectfully ask the Council to support both the temporary moratorium and the No Staging
policy before you this evening.
Thank you for your service to the people of Gilroy and for the seriousness with which you are considering
these matters. May your deliberations be marked by wisdom, compassion, courage, and a deep concern for
the common good.
Paz y Bien,
Anthony
The Rev. Anthony Suárez-Abraham, Associate Pastor
He / Él · Él / He | Why pronouns?
Advent Lutheran Church
Physical Address:
16870 Murphy Avenue
Morgan Hill, CA 95037
Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 607
Morgan Hill, CA 95038
Office phone: 408.779.3551
Mobile phone (call or text): 630.240.8586
We acknowledge living on the original and ancestral homeland of the Amah Mutsun Tribal Band people in what is
now called Morgan Hill. [To find the Indigenous origins of the land where you live, click HERE]
"You shall not unjustly mistreat an immigrant or an orphan; nor shall you take a widow's garment as collateral.
Remember that you were slaves in Egypt and the LORD your God redeemed you out from there. Therefore, I
command you to live this way." Deuteronomy 24:17-18