HomeMy WebLinkAboutAli Sapirman 5.1.pdf
October 14, 2026
Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
City of Gilroy
7351 Rosanna Street
Gilroy, CA 95020
Re: 2480 & 2740 Hecker Pass Road Residential Project (AS 23-19, TM 23-03), Draft
Environmental Impact Report
Dear Mayor and Councilmembers:
On behalf of the Housing Action Coalition (HAC), I write regarding the City's processing of the
2480 & 2740 Hecker Pass Road Residential Project (the Project) and its Draft Environmental
Impact Report (EIR). The Project, proposed by Mana Camden Fund, LLC, would build 116
single-family homes on 24.3 acres, including nine extremely low income units. HAC is a
member-supported nonprofit that advocates for more housing at all levels of affordability across
California, and we closely track local compliance with state housing law.
The Project is a Builder's Remedy application under the Housing Accountability Act (HAA),
Government Code section 65589.5, as amended by AB 1893 (2024). State law limits the City's
discretion over this Project, and the EIR must reflect those limits. As detailed below, the City's
handling of the Project and the Draft EIR do not. We urge the City to correct these issues in the
Final EIR and before the Project goes to hearing.
The City has repeatedly delayed the Project and its EIR. The City has continually, and seemingly
intentionally, delayed processing of the Project and preparation of its EIR. The applicant
submitted an SB 330 preliminary application on May 17, 2023. The City initially resisted the
Project's Builder's Remedy status until the Department of Housing and Community Development
confirmed it on October 17, 2023. Reaching completeness under the Permit Streamlining Act
then took roughly ten months.
The City also required an entirely new EIR rather than allowing the Project to tier off the existing
Hecker Pass Specific Plan EIR, even though a previously approved project on this same site
proceeded with a Mitigated Negative Declaration. The EIR consultant delivered an
administrative draft to staff on September 18, 2025. The applicant was told in January 2026 to
expect hearings in March or April 2026. The Draft EIR was not released until August 21, 2026,
and more than three years after the preliminary application, the Project has yet to reach a
decision.
Delay of this kind undermines the purpose of the HAA, which the Legislature directs to be
interpreted and implemented to afford the fullest possible weight to the approval and provision of
housing. The City should commit to a firm schedule for finalizing the EIR and bringing the
Project to a decision.
The City continues to apply standards that state law overrides.The City's comment letters on the
Project continually rely on requirements drawn from the General Plan, the Hecker Pass Specific
Plan, and the Zoning Ordinance. Under the Builder's Remedy, Government Code section
65589.5(d)(5), and related housing law protections, the City may not use inconsistency with
these standards to disapprove the Project or to condition it in a way that renders it infeasible.
Continuing to cite them as if they govern the Project misstates the City's authority and creates
confusion for the applicant and the public. The City's review letters of October 2, 2025, February
12, 2026, and April 15, 2026 all follow this pattern. For example, the City's April 15, 2026 letter
rejected the Project's proposed sound wall as inconsistent with Specific Plan Policies 4-5 and
5-68, standards the City cannot use to deny or condition a Builder's Remedy project.
The EIR improperly converts Specific Plan guidelines into mitigation. Many of the same
Specific Plan guidelines the City cites in its comment letters now appear as the basis for
mitigation measures in the EIR. This violates both state housing law and the limits CEQA places
on mitigation. In Tiburon Open Space Committee v. County of Marin (2022) 78 Cal.App.5th 700,
732, the First District Court of Appeal explained:
"Where a lead agency's discretion already is limited by legal obligations,
therefore, the scope of environmental review adjusts in relation to the amount of
discretion.… Accordingly, an EIR must reflect any applicable legal obligations
that limit the agency's discretionary authority, and thus the scope of review. And
while CEQA imposes a duty on lead agencies to avoid or mitigate significant
environmental impacts caused by projects, such duty exists only to the extent
feasible.… Mitigation measures that conflict with legal obligations are legally
infeasible and 'need not be proposed or analyzed.'"
(See also CEQA Guidelines, § 15126.4, subd. (a)(5); Pub. Resources Code, § 21004.) The City
cannot use the EIR to reimpose, through mitigation, standards that the HAA bars it from
applying directly.
The EIR ignores the HAA's limits on the City's discretion. Contrary to Tiburon, the EIR contains
almost no discussion of the HAA or the limits state housing law places on the City's authority
over this Project. Without that analysis, the EIR cannot accurately define the scope of the City's
discretion or identify which mitigation measures are legally feasible. The applicant has raised
these concerns for years, yet the City has refused to remove the measures that conflict with state
law. In a July 16, 2026 email, the City Attorney took the position that infeasible measures need
not be removed at the draft EIR stage. Leaving legally infeasible mitigation in the EIR confuses
the public, risks recirculation and further delay, and creates a pretextual basis for later denying or
conditioning the Project in ways the HAA prohibits. The Final EIR should include a clear
discussion of the HAA, the Builder's Remedy, and their effect on the scope of review and
mitigation. Where the City lacks authority to impose a measure, the EIR should say so, as CEQA
Guidelines section 15126.4(a)(5) allows.
Several mitigation measures must be removed or modified. Multiple mitigation measures in the
EIR are legally and practically infeasible, would reduce the Project's density, or both, and must
be removed. The applicant identified each one as inapplicable in its responses to the City's April
26, 2024 inconsistency analysis, and again after reviewing the administrative draft EIR:
● MM 6-1 (agricultural mitigation): Requires mitigating the conversion of 5.42 acres of
Prime Farmland under the City's Agricultural Mitigation Policy. Compliance would
require purchasing a significant amount of land and is not economically feasible.
● MM 6-3 (agricultural buffer): Imposes buffers from Specific Plan Policies 3-12 and 5-12
and the Agricultural Mitigation Policy. The applicant's site exhibit shows this would
eliminate at least eight lots, and the applicant has requested a State Density Bonus Law
waiver of the requirement.
● MM 9-2a, 9-2b, and 9-2c (South Hoey Barn): Require retaining the barn in place,
relocating it on site, or moving it onto a neighboring private property. Keeping it on site
reduces density, relocation is prohibitively costly, the barn has no foundation and
substantial rot, and the applicant cannot compel another landowner to accept it.
● MM 15-1 (traffic noise): Requires an earthen berm, a 145-foot setback, or reoriented
homes along Hecker Pass Highway, each of which reduces density or requires costly
redesign. The Project's proposed six-foot solid wood wall already achieves a 6 dBA
reduction according to a May 7, 2026 FCS noise report, and is prohibited only by Specific
Plan Policy 4-5, which cannot be applied here.
Measures that reduce density are independently barred. The City may apply its standards only in
a way that facilitates development at the density the Project proposes (Gov. Code §
65589.5(f)(1)), and may impose a condition resulting in lower density only with written findings,
supported by a preponderance of the evidence, of a specific, adverse impact on public health or
safety that cannot be feasibly mitigated another way (§ 65589.5(j)(1)). The City has made no
such findings. Where a measure cannot legally be imposed, the EIR should say so and treat the
impact as significant and unavoidable.
Other measures hold this Project to a stricter standard than comparable projects. The HAA bars
the City from imposing any requirement, process, or course of conduct that applies to a project
solely or partially because it is a Builder's Remedy project (Gov. Code § 65589.5(f)(6)(E)). Yet
the Mitigated Negative Declaration for an earlier, non-Builder's Remedy project on this same site
required none of the following measures, or far less:
● MM 8-2a and 8-2b (Swainson's hawk): The prior MND identified no Swainson's hawk
mitigation.
● MM 8-3 (Crotch's bumblebee): The prior MND did not identify the species.
● MM 8-4 (special-status bats): The prior MND did not identify bats.
● MM 8-5 (nesting birds): The prior MND included a much less stringent measure.
Nothing in the record suggests these species have become more likely to occur on the site. These
measures should be removed or revised to match the treatment of comparable projects.
HAC respectfully asks the City to remove the legally infeasible mitigation measures, modify the
measures that hold this Project to a heightened standard, add a full discussion of the HAA and
the Builder's Remedy to the EIR, and move the Project to a decision without further delay. The
applicant has already served formal notice that the City's conduct amounts to an effective
disapproval under Government Code section 65589.5(h)(6)(E), and resolving these issues now is
in everyone's interest. Gilroy needs more homes, and state law is clear about how projects like
this one must be reviewed. We welcome the chance to discuss these concerns with you and City
staff.
Sincerely,
Ali Sapirman
Advocacy & Policy Manager
Housing Action Coalition