HomeMy WebLinkAboutJan Bernstein Chargin 6.2.pdfCAUTION: This email originated from an External Source. Please use proper judgment and caution when opening
attachments, clicking links, or responding to this email.
From:Jan Bernstein Chargin
To:All Council Members; Public Comments
Subject:EXTERNAL - Camp Hope
Date:Monday, November 2, 2026 8:26:28 AM
Camp Hope is on the agenda again. Although I can’t be there in person I want to provide
input.
I also want to address the letter sent to the rest of council by members Hilton and Fugazzi,
because it includes serious inaccuracies and distortions and should not be the basis for
decision-making.
Camp Hope works. Not perfectly. And there are things we can and should do to make it better.
If that were Fugazzi and Hilton’s intention, to allow the camp to remain but take actions to
make it safer and better managed, I would be in support. But if the intention is to remove
Camp Hope and offer no alternative, then the stated concern for safety is disingenuous.
There is no doubt that the situation at Camp Hope is safer, cleaner, and better managed than
what will happen without it if no alternative solution is provided, and what already happens in
other areas of the city.
There have been deaths of multiple unhoused people in Gilroy this year — none of them at
Camp Hope. At Camp Hope there have been no overdoses, no people dying mysteriously in
their tents, or getting hit by cars while they were pushing carts across the street. There have
been no fires. Those tragedies affected people who were NOT at Camp Hope.
If we are really concerned about saving lives, we should start by worrying about the people
who sleep behind dumpsters, on benches, and behind buildings, the people who are alone
when they are in medical distress.
If the concern is sanitation, we should be fighting for additional port-a-potty locations around
the city, not trying to remove the ones used by residents of Camp Hope.
The rain has started, and El Nino is here. If people are not allowed to stay at Camp Hope they
will seek shelter under bridges, and then, when the water rises, in our parks and business
districts. They will not stop being homeless, they will not leave Gilroy, and they will not
cease to exist.
Hilton and Fugazzi made a few specific claims I need to refute:
1) They believe that camp residents have a locked gate and control who comes in and out. In
truth, the chain across the bikepath, that prevents vehicles from entering from Camino Arroyo
was placed there by Valley Water. Camp residents do not have a key, nor do they need one.
City crews have a key. The port-a-potty company has a key. Emergency providers have a key.
Pitstop Outreach has an encroachment permit from Valley Water that allows us access, and a
key to the lock, so we can provide services. (We had to complete an application, provide
insurance, and furnish a list of approved vehicles.)
Camp residents do not have a key, and some of the volunteer groups who visit do not have a
key. They enter and leave on foot or by bicycle.
2) They seem to believe that people have to climb down a steep embankment to enter the
camp. People do not have to climb down an embankment to enter the camp — they use the
flat, paved bike trail, which runs adjacent and remains open to the public. The city has place a
large dumpster, temporarily, which still leaves enough space for people to go around.
3) ADA compliance: There is a wheelchair accessible port-a-potty, along with the others. and
a handwashing station.
4) Warming fires: Camp Hope does not permit fires for warming or cooking.
5) I don’t know what to make of the paragraph with the bold heading “violence” that does not
contain any descriptions or examples of violence.
6) The “reset” - no one was ordered off the site and then invited back to take ip residence. On
the October clean-up days, tents were left standing while garbage and discarded materials
were removed by the San Jose Conservation Corps.
7) They are concerned that Camp Hope is in violation of the poorly-written and unenforceable
ordinance passed by the city several years ago to prevent encampments near schools and in
parks. Camp Hope is not near either.
My recommendations:
1) Amend the anti-camping ordinance by adding the following sentence “Nothing in this
ordinance prevents the city council from authorizing the provision of services for the
homeless, including a organized camping area, on city property, at Council’s discretion .”
2) Create an MOU between the city and service providers to ensure that insurance is in effect,
ADA rules are being followed, and fire safety measures are in place.
I would be very much in favor or a formalized agreement, safety standards, and an MOU with
the city that spells out responsibilities and requirements for keeping the camp open. An
agreement with a service provider would make it possible to secure funding for staff to
manage oversight and maintenance, and report on outcomes, or even to purchase new,
matching tents that would improve the appearance of the camp. It would also remove the
uncertainty that makes planning difficult for all parties.
The long-term solution is to create Permanent Supportive Housing located in Gilroy for our
residents who need it.
Thank you for your consideration.
Jan Bernstein Chargin
PitStop Outreach